Thursday, December 29, 2011

In Rhode Island, Is it Worth Selling Pharmacy Notes at a Discount?

By Brad MacLiver
Authorship and profile at Google


When a RI pharmacy acquisition has been accomplished by using the private financing method of a pharmacy business note, the holder of the pharmacy note has the option of selling the pharmacy business note for a lump sum of cash instead of waiting for the monthly payments and taking the risk those payments will always be made. Pharmacy business notes can be sold by using a discounting method. Instead of buying a pharmacy note at its face value, the Rhode Island pharmacy note will be discounted. Meaning the Investor will pay less than face value due to the risk being transferred from the Pharmacy Note Holder (the note seller) to the Pharmacy Note Investor (the note buyer).

Most Rhode Island pharmacy business note sellers only look at the discount rate and quickly calculate in their head that they are giving up too much money to make the selling of the pharmacy note an attractive proposition. However, further analysis needs to be completed before a final decision is made by weighing the discounted amount with the benefits of a lump sum of cash.

1. What is the motivation for selling the RI pharmacy note? What are the desired goals? Is reducing the exposure to risk a consideration? Is there a financial decision to pay off debt? Is capital required for a new venture? Are there dreams of exotic vacations or world travel that could be accomplished with a lump sum of cash? How important is it to accomplish these goals? What are the opportunity costs if you don’t have the lump sum of cash to achieve your goals, or invest in something that pays a higher return? Determine investment and family priorities.

2. What is the Current Fair Market Value of the pharmacy business? This is what someone is really willing to pay for the business, and not just an “earnings times x” formula. Real aspects of what is happening in the pharmacy industry must be considered and it is advantageous to have a pharmacy industry specialist in Rhode Island calculate the pharmacy business valuation.

3. How much cash is immediately required by the holder of the pharmacy note?

4. A pharmacy note in Rhode Island that is seasoned has more value than a “green” note that doesn’t have a payment history. Are you willing to hold the note for a certain amount of time to allow the business buyer time to prove to an Note Investor the capability of the payor making the payments?

5. Are you willing to sell only a portion of the Note (this is called a “Partial Sell”)? The discount rate can be a more attractive proposition when only a portion of the note is sold and the Pharmacy Note Investor is not holding all the risk.

Understanding the Risk for the Note Buyer:

1. Pharmacy Buyer Competency - There is the risk that the pharmacy buyer in Rhode Island may not run the business as efficiently as you have. The pharmacy business buyer may be unable to meet payment obligations, or sales could drop. Incompetency potentially leads to late payments, missed payments, or bankruptcy.

2. Changes in the Pharmacy Industry - Changes that are caused by influences either within the industry or by regulations governing the industry may make it increasingly difficult for the Rhode Island pharmacy business buyer to meet the contractual financial obligations.

3. Future Competition - Sales or income of the store might be affected by unforeseen RI pharmacy competition either building in the neighborhood or through mail order.

4. Loan to Value - When a pharmacy business note is originated, you may be creating a financing situation with a “negative loan to value.” Example: the pharmacy business note in RI is for $650,000, but there is only $250,000 of tangible assets for collateral.

5. Title Insurance – Rhode Island pharmacy business notes don’t have title insurance that will make good a loss arising through defects of titles, or liens.     

6. Time Value of Money - When a dollar received today has more value than a dollar received in the future.

7. Opportunity Costs - When the selection of holding the RI pharmacy business note ties up capital and prevents potential financial gains from other investments.

It is a good idea to discuss all available options and potential origination of a pharmacy note with Pharmacy Business Note Investor before the Purchase and Sale Agreement is finalized for the acquisition of the pharmacy. This provides the Rhode Island pharmacy business seller, and future note seller, valuable insight into structuring the pharmacy business note so it can be successfully purchased.

************************